GunCritic Logo

Benelli SuperNova VS Winchester SXP Defender

Head to Head Comparison

Benelli SuperNova

Guncritic Icon
87%

Critic Rating

16 Reviews

Guncritic Icon
94%

User Rating

72 Reviews

Winchester SXP Defender

Guncritic Icon
82%

Critic Rating

3 Reviews

Guncritic Icon
75%

User Rating

2 Reviews

50 MOA

Accuracy

50 MOA

75.97 Yeets

Damage

N/A

50-100 yards

Range

50-100 yards

N/A

Recoil Velocity

N/A

4+1 rounds

Capacity

5 rounds

N/A

Mobility

N/A

50

Ergonomics

50

50

Fit & Finish

50

50

Reliability

50

MSRP:

$494.10

Used Price:

$494.10

New Price:

$549.00

MSRP:

$400.99

Used Price:

$400.99

New Price:

$400.99

Gun Specifications

Specifications

Benelli SuperNova

Winchester SXP Defender

Length

49.5"

Action

Pump

Pump

Caliber

12 GA

Capacity

4+1

5

Finish

Black

Gun Type

Shotgun

Sights

Bead Front Sight

Barrel Length

28"

Gun Stats

Recently Deals

Benelli SuperNova

Guns.com

$541.98

See Deal

Brownells.com

$1529.99

See Deal

MidwayUSA

$549.00

See Deal

Guns.com

$541.98

See Deal

Sportsman's Warehouse

$541.98

See Deal

GrabAGun

$541.98

See Deal

Cheaper Than Dirt

$541.98

See Deal

Optics Planet

$541.98

See Deal

KYGUNCO

$1514.99

See Deal

EuroOptic.com

$541.98

See Deal

Academy Sports + Outdoors

$541.98

See Deal

Firearms Depot

$541.98

See Deal

Winchester SXP Defender

Gun Descriptions

Benelli SuperNova

The Benelli Supernova is a pump action shotgun used for hunting, self-defense and law enforcement, made by Italian firearm manufacturer Benelli Armi SpA. The Supernova features a recoil reducer, which is attached to the interior of the stock, and raises the length of time that the shot's impulse is spread across, thus lowering felt recoil.

Winchester SXP Defender

Easy to pack and carry, handling buckshot or rifled slugs efficiently through the fully chrome plated, 18" fixed cylinder choked barrel (no constriction) for wide patterning. This open choke is also very accurate when using Foster-type slugs. It also has non-glare metal surfaces with a tough composite stock and forearm. Additional features include a five-shot magazine (plus one in the chamber), and a positive, deeply grooved forearm for control and stability. Whether it's multi-gun competition or protecting your home and family, the Super X Pump Defender is the perfect choice. Its inertia-assisted action, six-shell total ammo capacity, durable composite stock and ribbed forearm give you an edge against any odds.

Suggested Comparisons

Winchester Sxp Defender vs Remington 870 Tactical

Winchester Sxp Defender vs Remington 870

Remington 870 Express Tactical vs Winchester Sxp Defender

Remington 870 Express vs Winchester Sxp Defender

Winchester Sxp Defender vs Benelli Nova Tactical

Winchester Sxp Defender vs Mossberg 590

Winchester Sxp Defender vs Mossberg 590A1

Remington 870 vs Winchester SXP Defender

Winchester SXP Defender vs Remington 870 Express Tactical